Hemorrhagic shock, drag-reducing polymers and 'spherical cows'

It was a pleasure to read the elegant and witty commentary by Gutierrez and Fuller [1] regarding our paper published in Shock [2] on resuscitation of rats using our aloe-derived drag-reducing polymer (DRP) solution. However, we disagree with the statement that, 'the application of physical principles to complex living organisms often requires assumptions ad absurdum.' There is always physics behind every natural process, including physiological processes in living organisms and hemodynamics. This is a well established and widely recognized philosophical and methodological principle. The physical explanation of systems characterized by extreme complexity is a very difficult task that requires many levels of approximation. Concerning the effects of DRPs on blood circulation in general, and the hypoperfusion associated with hemorrhagic shock in particular, several synthetic (polyethylene oxides, polyacrylamides) and natural (polysaccharides, DNA) DRPs with completely different chemical structures were found to produce exactly the same hemodynamic effects when injected in blood at minute concentrations. The similarity in effects observed with chemically distinct classes of compounds with DRP-like activity supports the notion that the beneficial effects are due to shared physical properties of these agents. We hope that readers of this journal will find time to examine another report on the treatment of hemorrhagic shock in rats using two high molecular weight polymers, which was published in February 2004 in Biorheology [3]. The polymers were synthetic polyethylene oxide (or polyethylene glycol [PEG]) with a molecular mass of 3500 kDa (PEG-3500) and the aloe-based DRP with a molecular mass of about 4000 kDa. In addition, we used PEG with a much lower molecular mass of 200 kDa (PEG-200) in these experiments. PEG-3500 and the aloe vera derived agent are DRPs. PEG-200 possesses the same chemistry and structure of the higher molecular weight PEG, but it has no drag-reducing ability (the drag-reducing property was found in linear polymers with molecular masses > 1000 kDa). The major findings were that the nanomolar concentrations of both DRPs added to the resuscitation fluid prevented death in rats from severe hemorrhage. However, PEG-200 did not produce any beneficial effects when it was added to the resuscitation fluid at 15 times the concentration. Thus, drag-reducing or related viscoelastic properties of the applied polymers were the most important factors in the improved survival from severe hemorrhage. Incidentally, we did not 'attribute systemic hemodynamic changes to decreases in vascular frictional forces' in our analysis of the obtained results. On the contrary, …